The
Wrong Way to Sell Democracy to the Arab World
March 8, 2004
Zbigniew Brzezinski, National Security Advisor
in the Carter Administration, expresses his views on President
Bush’s “Greater Middle East Initiative”
in a March 8th Op-Ed in the New York Times entitled, “The
Wrong Way to Sell Democracy to the Arab World.”
Here is our summary of his opinion piece:
Arab leaders
perceive the “Greater Middle East Initiative”
to be an American effort to impose change, and though the
program is meant to be voluntary, some fear that compulsion
would not be far behind. Brzezinski asserts that the Bush
administration’s proposal is out of sync with regional
realities, and that the proposal is fashioned like the restructuring
of post-WWII Europe rather than in harmony with the situation
in the Middle East. Rather, Brzezinski says, the Bush administration
needs to work out a proposal with Arab leaders before presenting
it to the G-8, so that Arab leaders would not find it in conflict
with their cultural and religious identity. Second, the initiative
would need to recognize the necessity of a political dignity
derived from self-determination; otherwise elections could
lead to the empowerment of extremist, militant or authoritarian
leaders. Lastly, the Bush Administration needs to define the
substance of an Arab-Israeli peace settlement in the Middle
East. Doing so would give credibility to the constructive
motives behind the democracy initiative.
|