“Ethiopian
Elections Key to Advancing Democracy in Africa”
By Jim Fisher-Thompson
Washington File Staff Writer
May 11, 2005
It is hard to see democracy expanding throughout Africa if
a populous nation like Ethiopia -- a country of enormous political
and strategic importance for the African continent -- drifts
toward "corrupt authoritarianism," says Dave Peterson,
Africa program director of the National Endowment for Democracy
(NED).
Peterson told a May 5 hearing of the House Subcommittee on
Africa that is looking into political stability in the Horn
of Africa region that with parliamentary elections set for
May 15, "democracy is in Ethiopia's own best interest
and the U.S. needs to help."
Peterson said NED is doing its part by funding initiatives
to train people at the grassroots level in democracy issues.
"So far this year we have made $312,213 in grants for
projects in Ethiopia, and we intend to allocate an additional
$160,000 by the end of the year with special funds approved
by the Congress," he said.
He told lawmakers, "There can be no doubt that Ethiopia
is far better off in terms of respect for human rights, political
pluralism, free press and economic policies than … at
any other time in its history." But the expulsion just
before the elections of three other democracy NGOs -- the
National Democratic Institute (NDI), the International Republican
Institute (IRI) and the International Foundation for Electoral
Systems (IFES) -- was an unjustified and arbitrary act that
is cause for concern, he said.
Time is running out for the institutes that specialize in
training election officials at the grassroots level, Peterson
said, adding, “We hope the Ethiopian government will
soon reverse its decision.”
In general, Peterson said, “I think it is worthwhile
for the United States to continue to press Ethiopia to allow
greater openness. I do not think Ethiopia can afford the luxury
of taking a lot of time in its democratic development. Nor
do I believe that its poverty should be considered an insuperable
obstacle to freedom.”
Peterson contradicted the argument by some officials that
Ethiopians do not want or need reforms: “On the contrary,
our experience in Ethiopia has suggested that its citizens
understand and desire democracy, and that many of the country's
political and economic problems may be more readily addressed
in a more open and democratic system.”
With Ethiopia on the verge of either joining the community
of democratic nations or stagnating into a kind of corrupt
authoritarianism, reform is critical in this second most populous
nation in Africa, Peterson said. “It becomes so important
now to invest strategically in the country and tip the balance
in the right direction,” he said.
Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs Donald
Yamamoto also said the fate of the NGOs was “troubling
and confusing, especially since it is the first time these
organizations have been expelled from any country.”
He told lawmakers: "Their expulsion on the eve of parliamentary
elections raises questions about that process. It also raises
questions about the government's commitment to real, meaningful
democratic reforms and the development of truly democratic
institutions."
Contrary to the claim by the Ethiopian government that the
NGOs did not follow proper procedures for registration, Yamamoto
said the U.S. government made a formal response to the Ethiopian
government “noting in detail the actions of these organizations
to file the appropriate documents with various Ethiopian governmental
authorities."
“These organizations did not enter into Ethiopia surreptitiously,”
Yamamoto said. “They acted with the full knowledge and
in full sight of the government.” Therefore, "we
have asked the government to allow these reputable organizations
to return to Ethiopia to continue their important capacity-building
work in advance of the election."
Asked by Representative Donald Payne (Democrat of New Jersey)
why the Ethiopian government was allowing The Carter Center
to monitor the election and not the others, Yamamoto said
he could not answer that question. But Subcommittee Chairman
Christopher Smith (Republican of New Jersey) jumped in to
say that it might be a belief that The Carter Center would
be less critical in its evaluation of the electoral process.
Referring to the expulsions, Smith told the hearing: “Today,
a number of colleagues joined me in sending a letter to Ethiopian
Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, urging him to rescind the expulsion
of three American NGOs helping to build democracy. …
For the sake of continuing democratic progress in Ethiopia,
we hope the prime minister will respond positively to our
request.”
|