Democracy News

CEIP Releases “Will Rising Democracies Become International Democracy Supporters?”
July 19, 2011
By: Carlos Aramayo | Printer Friendly

In July 2011, the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace released “Will Rising Democracies Become International Democracy Supporters?” The report addresses the rise of upcoming democracies (Brazil, India, South Africa and Turkey) in the developing world and their impact in reshaping the new international democratic order.

According to the report, these emerging economic powers have a history of democratic transitions that could be “compelling stories with both inspirational power and practical utility for other countries still mired in authoritarianism or attempting democratic transition.” However, the report also identifies that these countries are also leading exponents of the “sovereigntist” notion of international relations.

In addition, the report highlights the fact that “a deep-seated suspicion of the very concept of democracy promotion as being a rhetorical cover for assertions of Western geostrategic hegemony undercuts their willingness to embrace the issue publicly”. Moreover, in their quest for economic consolidation and expanding their influence, these emerging democracies are searching for new allies and trading partners. According to the report, this process makes them “wary of endangering commercial ties through antagonistic pressure on democracy and human rights.”

The report recommends that European and American diplomacy set their expectations at a reasonable level and keep “an open mind with regard to different and potentially clashing approaches on international democracy support.” Additionally, the report states that any type of cooperation will be “hindered unless the US and EU are honest with themselves and others about the (very old) issue of double standards.” In conclusion, the report recommends emphasizing low-visibility, sustained endeavors, not high-visibility, short term impact gestures.

To read the full report, click here.